I’ve been hearing that this commentary was coming for many years and it’s always been said that when it arrived it would be a good one. I’ve been reviewing commentaries for several years now and have much experience in even reading about some scholarly subjects that are beyond the scope of my personal interests. One thing is clear to me, when it comes to a detailed scholarly commentary on a book of the Bible, we are in the hands of a master in this volume.
It’s not that he takes a completely different approach to the task of writing a commentary. No, all the usual subjects are found in the introduction and what is explained in the commentary proper is within the usual parameters. It’s the deftness, proficiency, and expertise that shows up in paragraph after paragraph.
The icing on the cake is the generally conservative conclusions that are given. Sometimes you have a person who is a whiz at writing a commentary yet who concludes nonsense, but you will not find that here even though some scholarly subjects are so esoteric that you wonder why scholars even trouble themselves with it.
Instead of breaking down all the things covered in the introduction as I usually do, I’m going to skip to the chase. If you are building a first-rate scholarly library you simply must have this volume. There’s really no debate. I’ll make a prediction too: this commentary will be one of the most quoted on Amos in scholarly works for at least 25 years. Pastors will want other works too, but this is THE scholarly work on Amos now that it’s been released.
I received this book free from the publisher. I was not required to write a positive review. The opinions I have expressed are my own. I am disclosing this in accordance with the Federal Trade Commission’s 16 CFR, Part 255.
4 thoughts on “Amos (NICOT) by M. Daniel Carroll R.”
Pingback: Amos (NICOT) by M. Daniel Carroll R. | Talmidimblogging
Pingback: Amos (NICOT) by M. Daniel Carroll R. – Ayuda Ministerial/Resources for Ministry
I think Carroll was very well positioned and entitled to write this commentary, based on his previous authorship of a commentary on the same book. I met Carroll when he was teaching OT at Denver Seminary, but back then he was very focused on writing books about immigration in the USA. He wrote outstanding books on that topic, but I always thought inside of me, “o man, I hope he goes back to writing commentaries.” I’m glad he did. Looking forward to read this commentary soon. Thank you for the review.
So interesting! I didn’t know about his other writing.